i dont get u ppl these 2 movies are in my top 5 greatest films that came out in the last 5 years i just dont get how u can judge one to be soo much better then the other i dont get how sin city sucks and watchmen is in ur top 20 or watchmen was boring and sin city is the greatest movie ever made these are 2 great films and one should not be dismissed for the other these movies are bolth so great