with the woman after I parted from Richmond???I did not know Cook before that night, I had never spoken to her???I did not see a man who Charlwood said was her brother-in-law; she said there was a man there, and walked away; I do not remember seeing him???she did not point him out to me and say he was her brother-in-law???she said she' did not want to see him; she said There is a man there I don't