Some people muddle the cherry as well (and the last bar I worked at called for this in their recipe), but the ingredients never change, except for simple syrup subbed for a sugar cube. ...Posted on O-T LoungeJump to Post - View Topic - Replies (2) O-T Lounge re: So I ordered an old-fashioned last night, and bartender puts rock candy in it - thebert4130 on 2/21/15 at 11:48 amCherry juice?