I pointed out that the both axial stone circles and stones rows were clearly not aligned on any of the cross quarter days .Of the wedge tombs in the study approx 14 % are aligned on the setting sun at Samhain which in itself is noteworthy but the description of Oct/Nov as used in the paper is quite a bit wider than Samhain itself , some examples e.g. nos 2&58 were three weeks away from the the act